Six Obstacles to the Development and Commercialization of Marine Energy Devices


PMI - Ocean Wind Energy

Marine energy is a beguiling concept because our oceans have massive energy potential. Oceans can produce kinetic energy and store solar energy, both of which can be converted into electricity to replace fossil fuels that contribute to global warming.

But surface water on our planet also produces significant challenges: it’s turbulent, corrosive and teeming with life. Coastal areas are pivotal to local economies. Developing marine energy devices to tap the energy of the world’s oceans is rife with difficulties that boil down to six pivotal concerns.

Cost of Development

There’s no way to avoid the huge costs of developing first-generation marine energy technologies. For instance:

  • Scientists must get funding to develop and test hypotheses.
  • Engineers must find practical ways to convert research findings into effective mechanisms.
  • Prototypes must be developed using components that can withstand brutal ocean environments.

And all this must happen before moving to the manufacturing process, which imposes a new set of development costs.

Legal and Regulatory Hurdles

Oceans are shipping lanes and fisheries. Coastlines are prime tourist destinations. Waterways play a huge role in economies around the world, and all economies have legal and regulatory challenges.

These are the complications entrepreneurs have to think about before they wade into the uncharted waters of marine energy development. They’re reluctant to pour a lot of time, energy and money into projects that could get mired in litigation and regulation.

Political Support

It’s one thing to bring a new car factory to town with the potential to create thousands of jobs. Marine energy device developers can’t make those kinds of promises.

Also, marine energy is so new that few people at the political level understand its potential. That makes it difficult to rally voters who can lean on politicians to encourage marine energy development.

Also, public subsidies for renewables development can become extremely controversial if voters decide they haven’t gotten a good return on their investment. Because all politics is public, developers might not want to see their names in the headlines if their projects become a political liability.

Social Support

The public also has no idea of the potential for marine energy devices, so it’s hard to tap a deep vein of public popularity to encourage investors and entrepreneurs to enter the sector.

Furthermore, devices could be installed in places where the public can see them and object to changes in their favorite scenic ocean views. And they might wonder about what will happen to our oceans if we install these devices in them.

Environmental Concerns

All waterways are delicate ecosystems that are easy to knock out of balance. Installing rigid metal devices on the sea floor will create artificial reefs that could lure invasive species that have a survival advantage over the animals that are already there.

Devices also generate sounds that can affect some subsea species. The spinning blades of subsea turbines can potentially kill or injure fish and aquatic mammals.

Large numbers of devices in the water might also interrupt the migration patterns of fish and mammals, tripping up local fishers that depend on them for their livelihoods.

Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE)

Levelized cost of energy (LCOE) is a complex calculation that can be used to compare the cost-effectiveness of competing energy sources. For instance, the LCOE of offshore wind installations is about two-and-a-half times higher than land-based wind power, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration.

Post renewable energy sources have substantially higher LCOE than natural gas or coal, and some estimates say that marine energy devices have a LCOE as much as double that of natural gas or coal.

All of these challenges await anybody who ventures into the marine power device sector. The risks are large, but the rewards of devising technologies that can free us from fossil fuel dependencies could be even bigger — especially to those who come up with the most transformative devices.


Have time to discuss ideas? Click Request A Quote and we’ll be in touch shortly.

Request a Quote

PMI Industries, Inc. is currently experiencing a system outage affecting access to our customer-related services, including order placement, shipment, and fulfillment, and impacting electronic and telephonic communications with our business and sales representatives. Our IT team is currently addressing this issue and working to restore these functions as soon as possible. The outage may impact delivery and receipt of emails sent to PMI Industries, Inc. and its representatives during this time. Communications sent during this outage may not be received by the intended recipient even after the issue is resolved. We apologize for the interruption in service and appreciate your patience as we work to resolve this outage. We will provide updates on the latest information as to when our services will be restored as it becomes available.**Update: We are expecting email services to be operating normally by Tuesday, February 18th.